Three Acquitted in US$2,000 Shurugwi Armed Robbery Case
By Dumisani Ndlovu — Three men have been acquitted following a contested armed robbery trial, citing weaknesses in the State's evidence, including the failure to call a material witness linked to the recovery of a cellphone.
Gweru — Three men who were on trial for an alleged armed robbery involving US$2,000 and two mobile phones in Shurugwi have been acquitted after the prosecution failed to establish its case beyond reasonable doubt.
Takudzwa Yotamu (24), Lovemore Shoko (25) and Tafadzwa Hove (22) were cleared of all charges by Gweru Regional Magistrate, Archie Wochiunga, following a fully contested trial.
The State had alleged that during the final week of April 2026, the trio, acting individually or in concert, robbed Tinashe Pesanayi at Plot 1, Circle V, Shurugwi.
Prosecutors alleged that the accused used violence and threats while armed with a pistol and machetes to steal US$2,000 in cash, a Samsung cellphone and an H-Mobile phone.
However, in his ruling, Magistrate Wochiunga identified significant weaknesses in the prosecution's evidence, particularly the failure to call material witnesses and adequately establish the connection between the accused and the alleged stolen property.
The magistrate questioned the State's failure to summon Florence Manjengwa, who was allegedly found in possession of the stolen Samsung cellphone after reportedly purchasing it from Yotamu.
Her absence meant that the circumstances surrounding the alleged purchase and recovery of the phone were not properly tested through her testimony.
The magistrate also scrutinised the evidence relating to the identification of the alleged perpetrators, noting inconsistencies in the complainant's account and his explanation for not initially disclosing the identities of the people he claimed to have recognised.
The court further considered evidence that a pistol had been recovered underneath the driver's seat of a vehicle driven by the first accused, Yotamu, when police stopped the vehicle on June 16, 2026.
However, the recovery of the firearm did not, on its own, establish that the accused had participated in the robbery.
In assessing the prosecution's case, Wochiunga observed that there were deficiencies in the evidence linking the accused to the offence.
He further observed that without the necessary supporting evidence, the court could not safely conclude that the accused had committed the alleged offence.
The ruling underscored the importance of establishing a direct evidential connection between an accused person and the crime, rather than relying on suspicion or isolated pieces of evidence.
The magistrate reiterated that the burden of proof in criminal proceedings rests with the prosecution, which must establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
The accused persons are not required to prove their innocence.
The failure to produce material witnesses and adequately substantiate crucial aspects of the allegations ultimately resulted in the acquittal of all three men.



