Newcastle Climate Protest Faces NSW Police Court Challenge

By Harry Taruva —Police have asked the Supreme Court to prohibit Rising Tide's planned November 14 climate protest at Newcastle's coal port, citing safety concerns. The organisers are defending their right to peaceful assembly.

Newcastle Climate Protest Faces NSW Police Court Challenge
. Josh Pallas, legal director at Climate Defenders Australia.

Sydney – New South Wales Police have taken climate activist group Rising Tide to the Supreme Court in an attempt to stop a planned protest at the Port of Newcastle on Saturday.

The court challenge, scheduled for a hearing on Wednesday, comes after the police commissioner applied to prohibit the public assembly, despite the organisers having formally notified authorities of their intention to hold the event nearly two months ago.

Rising Tide plans to stage its Paddle for the Planet protest on November 14, involving a paddle-out at the Port of Newcastle, the world's largest coal export port, and family-friendly activities at Horseshoe Beach.

The demonstration is intended to call for a transition from coal, new employment opportunities and funding for affected coal workers, as well as measures to protect the climate.

The organisers have distinguished the event from their separate People's Blockade campaign, which involves attempts to disrupt port operations.

Climate Defenders Australia, which is representing Rising Tide in the proceedings, said the group submitted a Form 1 Notice of Intention to Hold a Public Assembly to police on September 17, as required under New South Wales law.

The notice is intended to give police advance warning of planned public gatherings so they can allocate resources and make arrangements for public safety.

However, the police commissioner launched the court challenge on November 5, prompting criticism from the organisers over the timing of the proceedings.

Police have cited serious safety concerns surrounding the proposed on-water demonstration. Organisers, however, maintain that Paddle for the Planet is not a blockade and is intended to be a peaceful event. 

Dr. Josh Pallas, legal director at Climate Defenders Australia, said the legal challenge raised important questions about the right to peaceful assembly.

“This case is important for protest rights, as our client tries to have a short and safe protest on waters that carry Australian coal out of the country,” he said.

He also questioned the use of public resources to oppose the demonstration, arguing that governments should focus on addressing climate change and the future of coal-dependent communities.

“Coal in the Hunter is a red hot issue right now. Instead of heaping coals on the fire, governments could be listening to the science and transitioning away from fossil fuels today,” Dr. Pallas said.

The challenge comes amid wider tensions over Rising Tide's activities at the port and the safety implications of protests in an area used by commercial shipping.

NSW Police Minister, Yasmin Catley, has defended the police position, saying the safety of port workers and other harbour users must be protected.

“Protest is one thing. Endangering workers in their own workplace is another. I back NSW Police to put safety first,” Catley said in comments reported by local media.

Rising Tide said it had repeatedly contacted police seeking a response to its notice but received no formal opposition until November 5, seven weeks after submitting the document and just nine days before the planned demonstration.

Dr. Pallas said his legal team had been forced to prepare its case under considerable time pressure.

“The Commissioner sat on our client’s Form 1 Notice from 17 September until they commenced proceedings on 5 November. It’s hard to have a fair fight under these time constraints, but we are ready,” he said.

The demonstration is scheduled to run from 10am to 2pm, with the on-water flotilla planned between 11am and 1.30pm. Organisers expect hundreds of participants and have proposed deploying a floating banner during the event. Rising Tide +1

The protest is timed to coincide with the United Nations COP31 climate negotiations in Türkiye, where Australia is presiding over the negotiations.

Rising Tide has previously organised demonstrations against coal exports at Newcastle, with its activities attracting legal challenges and disputes over public safety and shipping operations.

Climate Defenders Australia said it had represented Rising Tide protesters in court proceedings across Australia.

Pallas said the organisation was optimistic that the Supreme Court would uphold the group's right to protest.